Home » Downloads » Respond to two colleagues by respectfully agreeing or disagreeing with their description of peer reviewed research or its comparison to other forms of writing.

Respond to two colleagues by respectfully agreeing or disagreeing with their description of peer reviewed research or its comparison to other forms of writing.

Respond to two colleagues by respectfully agreeing or disagreeing with their description of peer reviewed research or its comparison to other forms of writing.

Respond to two colleagues by respectfully agreeing or disagreeing with their description of peer reviewed research or its comparison to other forms of writing. Also address what role APA Style plays in a peer-reviewed research article.

Discussion: Peer-Reviewed Research Articles

A description of peer review is a process of subjecting an author’s scholarly work, investigation, or ideas to the scrutiny of professionals in the exact field(Kelly et al.,2014).

Peer review is significant because it serves two primary objectives(Kelly et al.,2014). First, according to Kelly,2014, peer review acts as a filter to ensure that only high-quality study is printed, particularly in reputable journals, by determining the study’s validity, significance, and uniqueness (Kelly et al.,2014). Second, Kelly, 2014, states that peer review enhances the rate of manuscripts considered appropriate for publication(Kelly et al.,2014).

Peer review is essential in social work education because it fosters self-analysis, examination, interpersonal relations, and recorded communication, which are critical skills required for professional social work practice (Lemieux, 2001).

Accordingly to Kelly,2014, what makes an article a peer-reviewed is that peer-reviewed articles provide a trusted form of scientific communication( Kelly et al.,2014). Additionally, peer review has become an essential component of the academic writing process within the scientific community(Kelly et al.,2014). It helps ensure that papers published in scientific journals answer meaningful research questions and draw accurate conclusions based on the professionally executed investigation; thus, the black book symbol (labeled ‘refereed’) reveals that the journal is peer-reviewed. (Kelly et al.,2014). Peer-reviewed (refereed) journal articles are written by professionals and examined by several additional professionals before publication to guarantee quality(Kelly et al.,2014).

Finally, the content and language of peer-reviewed research articles compared to other forms of writing is that non-peer-reviewed sources, such as newspaper articles, aren’t written by professionals on their topics(Kelly et al.,2014). Therefore, non-peer-reviewed material doesn’t receive peer review and is often biased to some degree. However, peer-reviewed is conducted by scientific experts with specialized facts on the manuscript’s content with a more broad knowledge base(Kelly et al.,2014).

Reference:

Kelly, J., Sadeghieh, T., & Adeli, K. (2014).

Peer Review in Scientific Publications: Benefits, Critiques, & A Survival Guide. EJIFCC, 25(3), 227–243.

Lemieux, C. M. (2001). Teaching for professional learning: Peer review, self-evaluation, and the problem of grading. Arete, 25, 58-70.

Answer preview to respond to two colleagues by respectfully agreeing or disagreeing with their description of peer reviewed research or its comparison to other forms of writing.

Respond to two colleagues by respectfully agreeing or disagreeing with their description of peer reviewed research or its comparison to other forms of writing.

APA

282 words

Get instant access to the full solution from yourhomeworksolutions by clicking the purchase button below

ABOUT

Yourhomeworksolutions is a one-stop shop for all your homework needs. You can purchase already completed solutions to be used as samples and you can order assignments to be done afresh by our competent writers.